30/05/2008 In Evolution of the Web by admin
I’ve been brewing this post for a couple days, since I first read Robert Scoble’s post theorizing the impacts of a Microsoft purchase of Facebook and Yahoo. Scoble’s post clearly reveals his Ideology towards a universally “Open and Public Web.” And that is where I stand in opposition to Mr. Scoble: I like my two webs, my three webs, my many webs.. locked off and seperate from eachother. I find value in that.
I have found that the closed web actually cultivates intimacy and privacy amongst smaller networks.. and this leads eventually to a deeper digital authenticity, which, in turn, bleeds out into Scoble’s open and public web (furthing a culture of empowered transparency). If we are talking about a web blooming with truth, heart, reality and real deep soaring community… I have found value in having that womb where that community can form, take root, get comfortable, discover intimacy with the medium. Find the the psychological skill and comfort in pursuing a publically transparent and socially collaborative life pattern.
Yes, the collision of the Microsoft Brand with Facebook would be the absolute shits. It would suck. And I would probably have to wonder off and find another closed network to play in. But I still want my closed web.
Scoble refers to this biforcation of the net as some dark manifestation that will stunt the evolution of the human net.
This is a fight for the Web. We all just crawled inside a box that locks Google out…Google is locked out of the Web that soon will be owned by Microsoft. We will never get an open Web back if these two deals happen…
If all this is true there is no way in hell that Facebook will open up now.
Can the open public Web fight back? Yes. It’s called FriendFeed. Notice that FriendFeed replaces almost all of Facebook’s killer features with open ones that are open to Google’s search.
This writer, in particular, has found extreme value in the closed off web that Facebook cultivates. I enjoy being able to interact with the vast network of my social history in a private and none-searchable arena.
I enjoy and find value in being able to communicate intimacies, daily life, plans, and stupidities in a digital playground that his neatly tucked out of reach from the tendrils of Google.
In that closed network I have allowed myself to explore a deeper digital authenticity with my friends and family; I have been able to cultivate real communication within my network.
None of that would have been occurred in an open and public web. We all would have continued to quietly pass notes under the table via email. It is through facebook that siblings and cousins and old classmates and ex-girlfriends and I have come together and begun experimenting with what it means to be REAL online. Where a deeper human-ness finds an online vocabulary. Where we can begin to test the waters gently with our toes.
Even as I delve into twitter, friendfeed, etc - I’m still discovering which elements and feeds of my daily life I want to offer up to the open web. And there are many aspects, many feeds, I don’t feel inclined to make public - yet, I do find value in offering them up to my private web.
I don’t feel in opposition to Scoble’s deeper truth. I get a sense the man has a deep, true and good heart. When he talks about this ‘open web’ he is talking about a web for the people and by the people.
Remember though, Mr. Scoble, you’ve been of the for-front of public and digital transparency… there are others of us, however, who are still finding rhythm in the world of social media. For us, Google can be scary, and it feels nice to have a little shelter from the Eye of Sauron. As the net evolves into a true medium for human intimacy and social evolution there is still a culture and comfort for the human psyche to be discovered and exlored.
I have faith in the free-market. I have faith in the evolution of human-kind. I have faith in the evolution of the net. And I feel that a diverse range of web ‘localities’ serves our greatest potential more than one would.
May the Force be with you.
image credits: window - SingSkateRocketLuv, girl - Ged80, hand - svenwerk